June 24, 2016
An article published on June 22, 2016, in Law360 reports that the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) issued its final written decisions in the covered business method reviews filed by Google Inc. and Apple Inc. against a digital rights management patent belonging to Fitch Even client ContentGuard Holdings Inc. The PTAB found the three challenged claims unpatentable, but in a rare move, also granted ContentGuard’s alternative motion to amend the independent claim, which the PTAB found patentable over the prior art.
The article, “ContentGuard's Claims Survive In Apple, Google Patent Row,” goes on to explain that the PTAB “further granted ContentGuard’s bid to hold that the amended claim is substantially identical in scope to the original claim within the meaning of 35 U.S.C. § 252, which potentially bestows upon accused infringers the protection of ‘intervening rights’ when an amendment is made during post-issuance proceedings that changes the scope of a claim.”
IP Alert | Stock Ownership Leads to Vacatur of $2.75B District Court JudgmentAugust 8, 2022
On June 23, in Centripetal Networks v. Cisco Systems, the Federal Circuit vacated judgment of the district court because stock held by the judge's wife violated the recusal statute and was not harmless error. Read more
IP Alert | Rehearing Reverses Earlier Federal Circuit Decision Finding Silence Supported Negative Claim LimitationJuly 6, 2022
On June 21, in Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation v. Accord Healthcare, Inc., a reshuffled Federal Circuit panel reversed course on rehearing to find that a negative claim limitation was not supported by silence in the patent's specification. Read more